Dunkman
Earlier this year
Cats @ JJs 2nd semi
Should be another good game in what has been a fantastic finals so far. Can cats back up the Perth win, I doubt it, JJs by 12.
Dunkman
Earlier this year
Should be another good game in what has been a fantastic finals so far. Can cats back up the Perth win, I doubt it, JJs by 12.
Ben
Earlier this year
I think Jacks will feed off the ravenous crowd. Closer margin of 3 or 4 points though.
Jimmyhooper15
Earlier this year
Not sure cats can win this even without Lee.
Luuuc
Earlier this year
I believe it is > 2 years since the Cats won in Tassie.
(Not that I think we're incapable of winning tonight, but I can see why the JJs are firm favourites)
Ben
Earlier this year
Big game like this and they've got that hack Lowery on mic. Oh dear.
MaxM
Earlier this year
Man it's nearly boiling over already in the first quarter...
Electric atmosphere
Dunkman
Earlier this year
Exactly, why Lowery. Crowd having an influence here,
Dunkman
Earlier this year
Doolittle is gun, JJs D has been horrible, Pinder is JJs heads.
Dunkman
Earlier this year
JJs been crap but only trail by eight, game on. Perth been very good. Monday night and the place is ripping.
Anon
Earlier this year
Commentary when driving dives on a glancing loose arm from cotton, well soft but there. When cotton goes down with more contact, still an exaggeration, there is too much diving. Ffs don't be so bias, if it's good for one it's good for the other.
Knockdown3
Earlier this year
Magnay on 3 fouls with 3:30 left in the 2nd.
Very hard for Tassie from here on
Luuuc
Earlier this year
Easier if Pinder's night is done though.
Wonder if he copped one in the same spot as his previous eye socket injury.
MaxM
Earlier this year
3 fouls for Doyle and Magnay.
Pinder is such a mystery, I wonder what's wrong?
Knockdown3
Earlier this year
That's what I'm thinking Luuuc, as there's seemingly nothing else that could be making him look so uncomfortable based on the replays.
Hopefully thats not the case for him.
Dunkman
Earlier this year
Sarr taking over very nicely from Pinder.
Luuuc
Earlier this year
Yeah, Sarr has been solid. Impressively composed so far.
GordonG
Earlier this year
Fun seeing all these ex-Taipans out there.
Pinder
Harris
Deng
Krslovic
Steindl
Dunkman
Earlier this year
Perth clearly been better, the fat lady isn't singing yet. The commentators been very average, Santa included. The MVP does get a few calls but it makes up for the ones he does not, how does he continue for 40 minutes, game in and out with the bashing he gets. Usher made some horrible reads, kept JJs in it. Good game and the crowd is unbelievable.
Anon
Earlier this year
Why won't the commentary complain about how sof that call on doolittle was? Seriously same contact on bc where you made a song and dance about it...
Anon
Earlier this year
Difference between that on pinder and when mcveigj dropped cottonn earlier ????
Drexler
Earlier this year
Im not a ref and i realise its a fast game but the amount of contact that gets you to the line varies from absolutely none to being mid air clotheslined play by play - for both teams. Always has always will be, the NBL!
Just
Earlier this year
That wasn't a foul from usher, that was just really bad defence.
Dunkman
Earlier this year
Pinder better get to his previous game standard or it all JJs.
Anon
Earlier this year
Ref's to the rescue, absolutely nothing wrong with the d from wags and dollitlle, had position and just standing upright, but red of the year is seeing fouls...
MaxM
Earlier this year
You just shouldn't be calling those fouls on Wagstaff and Doolittle in the 4th quarter of a playoff game
Diop Kick
Earlier this year
Technically blocks as the defender moved late but soft contact compared to other no calls in the game
Anon
Earlier this year
But no foul called when sarr clearly hit on the shot... steindl three the other way. 7-0 run to the ref's. This is why the league is a joke. The periods of impossible inconsistency that favours one team just ruins a game.
Diop Kick
Earlier this year
Magnay bullying Sarr, too strong and physical
BG
Earlier this year
Have they announced when a game 3 would be? Surely it doesn't clash with the WNBL Finals game 2 on Thursday in Perth
Another Anon
Earlier this year
5 fouls to zip in the 4th, all soft as butter
Anon
Earlier this year
Magnay grabs Webster's shirt hand in the backnon the goal tend layup no call. Seriously nbl better give perth the win game 3 cause that's all this quarter has been for tas. Absolutely ruined any game that was at play
Luuuc
Earlier this year
Sook it up all you want but the JJs have outplayed the Cats
Jacket
Earlier this year
If i was a referee i would soooo be gambling on games i officiate in to get extra money on the side.
Who would ever catch you?
Diop Kick
Earlier this year
agreed tassie executing better, need pinder firing if it goes to game 3
Luuuc
Earlier this year
Anon super-quiet when the questionable ones go the Cats' way I've noticed
Anon
Earlier this year
Well all the calls this quarter have gone one way. Most of the game was reasonably consistently avg. 4th has been a complete one way ride. Doyles check on Webster at mid court can't not be a foul in a game of basketball
Perthworld
Earlier this year
This ad placement would have been epic... two weeks ago.
Jacket
Earlier this year
Its almost like the league wants to series to go to game 3 to maximise revenue.
Company men
Maybe
Earlier this year
Has Deng managed tonight to convince the JJ's that he is worth a bench spot next season?
Anon
Earlier this year
Ref's took care of pinder. Tas played well, no doubt but they should have had one of Doyle or magnay fouled out to match pinder getting the treatment. 6 or 7 fouls to 0 to power them to the lead in the 4th. For mine it ruined the game, tas executed better, may have still won, but at least it would have been worth watching a game of basketball. This was soft free throw procession all one way to get them the lead in the 4th. If perth loses I can deal, happy to be most critical on my team. That didn't feel like the players controlled the outcome, which has been this leagues problem year after year game after game. Soft as crap calls on perth, and an absence of soft as crap calls on tas all last quarter while it mattered.
Diop Kick
Earlier this year
Wildcats stopped being able score easily in the second half. That wasn't refs.
Luuuc
Earlier this year
For some reason there are people who just refuse to give credit where it is clearly due.
JJs cleaned up their messy early game (I wonder if they were a little too hyped up in the early going) and played smarter & harder basketball the rest of the way. And that was without Lee, and with Crawford doing SFA.
Dunkman
Earlier this year
JJs to good, Deng very good, Doyle obviously great, McDonald very good. Cotton closed down well after the half though never got a call. Cats been very good but Usher to hot and cold, Pinder likewise. Cats also lack a rebounding defensive four, Harris and Wagstaff toil hard but don't get it done. Doolittle fantastic in the three.
I can see a three v four GF, both united and cats lose at home.
Jacket
Earlier this year
LOL Perth had 1 FT the ENTIRE 2nd half
Look, the NBL is a business and they just want revenue and the best way to do that is to get more game 3s
Just deal with the reality
Perthworld
Earlier this year
I can see a three v four GF, both united and cats lose at home.
Knockdown3
Earlier this year
I don't understand why JR didn't run some plays for Saar in the low post in the 4th.
Get him to look to score (& get Magnay in foul trouble), and or pass out from the post to some cutters or kickout for a 3.
Was worth a try. Nothing else was happing inside for them offensively.
Sebastian
Earlier this year
Jacket, referees gambling, you have no idea that they all work together. All email accounts, gambling accounts are monitored. Officials on and off court, (including players) cannot bet on any form of basketball ( including NBA). So you my friend are alone in the gambling stakes .
KWhite_Rulez
Earlier this year
What a pickup Usher was for the Cats. Real champion he is.....
Jacket
Earlier this year
Sebastian.
Not saying they are gambling.
All i am saying is Tim Donaghy gambled on games he officiated on for years and ONLY got caught by pure accident by the FBI.
The NBA has absolutely no clue and imagine the resources they have compared to everyone else.
Anon
Earlier this year
No, i acknowledged tas improved their play, thay may have won in any case. But 20 fta to 1 in the first and second half with an almost identical shot chart is statistically highly unlikely. Factor in 7 or 8 fouls all on perth with 0 on Tasmania, again statistically this is highly unlikely to occur, I think most would agree tas were not perfect. But alas they weren't penalised. We will go to game 3 where perth will get the same treatment Tas got and everyone will complain about Perths home cooking.... funny how it works
Anon
Earlier this year
Ah Look another BS post by Jacket and another whinging post by anon.
Anon
Earlier this year
Is that how you want to see games called anon? Cause if the answer is yes then criticise away, if thebanswer is no then the "whinge" is warranted.
Jack Knife
Earlier this year
I feel that any chance in that game for Perth was lost in those few minutes at the start of the 4th when we had both Websters on and no Sarr or Pinder. Got absolutely smashed. A baffling rotation
koberulz
Earlier this year
Have they announced when a game 3 would be? Surely it doesn't clash with the WNBL Finals game 2 on Thursday in PerthThe WNBL game was initially Wednesday, once the Lynx made it through it was moved to Thursday specifically to avoid a potential clash with this game three on Wednesday.
McBlurter
Earlier this year
Next year I'm betting on the NBL semis for sure.
Whoever wins game 1, I'm backing the other side game 2.
Always 3 games by the looks of it
Sebastian
Earlier this year
Donaghy was 17 years ago dumb arse. Not only does the digital age make it more difficult but all the betting agencies are aligned with the league. And yes, you are implying that they are gambling you douche
Perthworld
Earlier this year
How low will the crowd be on a two day turnaround for what is traditionally the weakest phase of the playoffs attendance wise.
DR
Earlier this year
That coaches challenge on the ghost foul is a embarrassment for the ref involved . Why is he blowing his whistle on that . Should be stood down for game 3 . Btw the 6 refs doing these finals it's a boys club
LV
Earlier this year
Yeah good question PW
I was just thinking to myself, can't wait for Wednesday night, these two games might be epic! The only problem is.... it's a Wednesday night.
Perthworld
Earlier this year
Play-ins: Wednesday, Wednesday, Monday.
SF1: Thursday, Sunday, Wednesday.
SF2: Friday, Monday, Wednesday.
Beach Baller
Earlier this year
Nothing funnier than sooking Wildcats fans
They are the Collingwood fan of the NBL!
Knowall
Earlier this year
JJs should change their initials to HH..Head Hunters
Sebastian
Earlier this year
Hey DR if not for these 6 who in your opinion should be working finals on the whistle?
Baller
Earlier this year
Perth world I think game 3 is 50/50 between wildcats jack jumpers. But I think in the other one the hawks absolutely have United's number they dominated the first game and should have won that series should be over already
Dunkman
Earlier this year
The refs overall have been ok, it's just the few howlers they miss, plus a little bit of inconsistency. It’s a very difficult job, easy to see on tv and replays.
Jimmyhooper15
Earlier this year
McVeigh and Doyle essentially won the game. Compounding perths lost is Pinder looks injured or concussed.
Perthworld
Earlier this year
Perth world I think game 3 is 50/50 between wildcats jack jumpers. But I think in the other one the hawks absolutely have United's number they dominated the first game and should have won that series should be over already
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 8:45 pm, Thu 21 Nov 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754