Juice,
In everything the larger the sample size the more likelihood good decisions will be made. Friday night are the only thing that provides a large sample size. Further, the better VJBL, SA and NSW teams are far stronger than the weaker State teams, look at the ACT teams performances in the Classic, its absurd to suggest its not a meaningful indicator.
As in everything context counts. Scoring is important, and thre fac tis that if a kid can't score on Friday nights they are unlikely to do so at an AJC, how they score, their efficiency and the effect on their team performance are all important. To cherry pick from the kids listed above, Zoe Rakogianis has lead Knox to wins over Norths and Kilsyth in the Classic and Dandenong in VJBL, its obvious she is a winning player, not an empty volume scorer. The eye test shows she is tall, fast, a great ball handler, finisher and mid-range shooter, these are not things that are difficult to see. Last year in u16's Jasmine Perry was the competitions top scorer at over 20 per game, in a team that went to the Classic and finished 5th or 6th in VJBL with no talls after the first round of VC, also a winning player. Lily Carmody last year in u18's was not the same level of scorer but was an obviously pivotal player in the best performed team over the year in u18's and subsequently went straight into the WNBL, she also missed the u18 State team. I really don't care what went on at trials, those kids were obviously shafted the detriment of the Vic Metro teams.
To answer your query re the HP Coaches, well Screen is gone so that's a moot point. But definitely I think the program is better for her departure. Some of the changes her and Darren Best have made are ridiculous. Its well established that the later you leave talent ID the better, so they have gone and drastically reduced the number of u18's, some of whom will age out while they are still 16 and brought in FDP which has some kids as young as 10 in it. Talent ID at 10 is almost a useless exercise. Excluding kids from outside of SDP is equally ridiculous.