I'd be curious as to what part is surprising for those that tipped Adelaide to be that top-4 type team.
Granted, Humphries has been injured/unfit for longer than expected. However, it was never going to be fast, one of the two major reasons why an import PF/C was important.
With that said, Bairstow has been considerably better than expected which covers for that loss a bit.
I don’t think McCarron was ever going to solve all our problems, and would be a lot more troubling if he could run riot with two decent wings that require defensive attention. Otherwise teams will just focus and stifle MM.
The revolving door of players and coaches are an inherent disadvantage. Trying to fill a roster with lots of "average players" without a defined role and all expecting time on court is an inherent disadvantage. The one thing about Perth rosters or a guy like Teys is that the players knew their roles, knew what to expect and contribute and makes it easier to create a balanced roster.
Speaking of balance roster - Adelaide doesn’t have that, nor a style to reflect whatever type of eclectic roster this is.
I’d have liked to see:
C Bairstow (whilst Humphries is injured)
F Athletic styled def PF
F Athletic defender/perimeter threat - could be a taller guard
G Shooter
G McCarron
With a DJ, Dech, Tad providing the bench portion of main rotation.
For CJ - follow the Smyth playbook - generate your defence from your offence, focus more on fast pace licence to shoot offence and less on tactics and slow motion ball.
Given what they have now - IMO bring in that athletic shooting guard that can play SF. Make Hannahs exercise a licence to shoot, and thrill, particularly from the perimeter, instead of driving into defence.
Move Withers to just about a full time PF role. Pair him with IH when IH returns, and pair Bairstow/DJ together.
Help space McCarron with Hannahs and Import, and bring Dech in to provide that 3&D from the bench.
At the moment they are one X factor scorer and some Hannahs licence to shoot away from achieving space for MM.
Once you start getting buckets it applies pressure on the opposition to score, and that’s where MM and Dech provides good defence and Bairstow/Withers provide that helpful hard work down low.