Any team with Martin in it is not "best ever"
It's a quirky selection I'll admit, but go back and watch the 2016 finals. And I'd argue that wasn't even his best.
That's the quirky thing when you say "best ever". We didn't often see the best of Martin offensively, but when we did get both he was incredible.
There's no way a Perth team can include Nick Kay, whom I love as a player. There's Crawford, Vlahov and Fisher in front of him.
Sigh, which is why I named those players, based on overall performance. But at his best, Kay is better.
That said, JC is an interesting option. Obviously I have based my selections on position, and his lack of range generally tags him as Centre, but a case could be made to select him at PF.
Stewart picks himself over Cotton?
I would pick Peter Crawford ahead of Stewart too. Maybe Harvey and Lisch as well
Cotton is the best ever in that position.
And yes, for overall contribution he already comes close, ask me again in a year or two