Lovebroker:
Mike Kelly should have received an F.
Given in the past you were critical of Fearne's record as coach and then later (when it suited you) you were very complimentary of his record and given you recently praised Loughton on his retirement and then not long after you said his greatest achievement was getting Beecroft to pay him the season he has just completed, I look forward to you posting in the near future about how good a job Kelly did in his first season of coaching!
Ben:
A- for Jarrod Kenny pretty much says it all for the 'journalist'
Perhaps A- is a tad too high, however Gerran's summary of the reasons for giving him that are spot on. Kenny was very good, particularly in the 2nd half of the season. He won the Coach's award at the end of season dinner.
In general, although some of Gerran's markings were a bit wonky, I thought most of the comments he made were reasonable enough. Trimble was entitled to an A- at least, I would have thought, and Krslovic should have received a similar mark to Kuany (C). Kuany did well when given minutes and was named Player's Player at the end of season awards night on Friday night.
The C mark that Gerrans gave Hall ( rather than a D others think he should have got) was warranted imo and I agree with Greybuoys comments in his post. Once he settled in, Hall was a solid all round contributor. Having Trimble and Newbill at the 1 and 2 spots limited his scoring opportunities I felt although he could have been more aggressive at the basket at times. He looked ok when he did that, I thought.
I also feel that Jawai offers a bit more to the team than most posters seem to think. Overall, he had a solid season and I wouldn't have a problem if he was signed for another 2 seasons. Yes, we pay overs for him but remember the Taipans do not pay all of this themselves. It's not like there are better options out there.
Where Kelly is concerned, taking everything into consideration, I thought he did a good job, with the 2nd half of the season being a big improvement on the first half. Next season will tell more about whether he will be a good long term coach.
As far as next season goes, I think bringing in a good import 4 and finding a decent Australian player to fill the 3 spot would help greatly. The latter is easier said than done though.