What about an under-performing list

1. Goulding
2. Brad Newley
3. AJ oglivy

Over-performing
1. L. Walker
2. S. Illi

I wouldn't say Shea Ili is overperforming, he's just a young bloke maturing as a player and figuring out how to get it done

Blanchfield's always been wildly overrated putting up numbers on bad Townsville teams. Good luck to him he's been riding that these last few years.

Lucas Walker has had a resurrection this season.

Ogilvy just seems to be temperamental than anything.

Cadee is just hot and cold. Has a great game, then goes missing for a few weeks. Probably needs some mentoring or something to get him playing hot week in week out.

for my money
most over-rated player - Goulding
most under-rated player - Vukona
worst player - Kevin White

How is Sobey overrated? Two seasons ago he was averaging 4 points a game. Last season 15ppg and league most improved player

Ogilvy - most overrated

Andersen - most disappointing

Pledger - most underrated

You can still be a good player and be overrated. Sobey should be classed more as disappointing because he hasn't reached the level of last season yet.

Snooch, the reason I think Sobey is over-rated this year is based on the reasons you state.
He was outstanding last year, and as such had a whole lot of expectation placed upon him by commentators / fans / etc.
I don't think he has even come close to delivering or displaying the "NBA level talent" that there was chat about. Hence, I think that this season; he is over-rated.

DKD is fortunate to even be on a roster.

Yet somehow Hire gets court time, and wtf does he even do out there!?

Kevoo White worst player to get regular minutes

Thoesby worst overall. He's a shooter who can't hit a shot

Hire is there to lift the intensity and get rebounds. He doesn't need to score to have an impact.
Overrated-Cadee (should not ever have been a Boomer)
Underrated- A healthy Jawai
Worst- Gibson (see Cadee)

Goulding's a shooter who can’t hit a shot.
Yet we hear commentary fan boys talking up his "NBA level talent" shooting.

Most misrepresented player.

I won’t even mention most misrepresented manager and coach.

Sobey has been awesome the past 2 games against Perth and NZ. Might have started playing into some form.

Each to their own with opinions.
For me overrated Moller , people talking like he is a future boomer.
Worst player Thoseby .

Good list, Frank! Love the under-rated, despite that Pledger & Vukona owe me one from a wager on Breakers today.

Under-rated:

Tom Jervis
Majok Majok
Rob Loe
Perrin Buford

Over-rated:

Mitch Norton
Jarrod Kenny
Stephen Weigh
Te Rangi
Greg Hire
Cadee

Worst:

Teys
Hooley
Doyle
James Hunter
Te Rangi
Pineau

Overrated

1. Jason Cadee. Will score 10, but oppponent will score 22 on him. Easily, the worst 1 on 1 defender in Australia, streaky shooter who can't really do anything but hit an open 3

Under rated

1. Perry Ellis been puttin up huge numbers. Is unguardable

Just plain crap

1. Todd blanchfield
2. Kevin White
3. Thoseby
4. Holt

Norton is having a disappointing season after the improvement he showed last year

Wagstaff is my pick for underrated.

Over and under rated depends who's rating. I'll go with exciting and disappointing

Exciting/ better than expected:
Walker
Humphries
Wagstaff- makes the right plays. Smart, crafty, plays a role to perfection.


Disappointing
Ogilvy- was a superstar with Sydney and in first yr under Bevo in 2015-16. What happened?
Goulding
Holt
Andersen
Norton- hasn't come along as much as I'd hoped

Agree Te Rangi has earned his over-rated spot but was the guy (& Trice) who hauled them over the line on Saturday.

Creek just has just had injuries consistently. Great player and great energy.

So who would be in the over-rated starting 5?

Seems like the consensus is

C Ogilvy
PF
SF
SG
PG

overrated kyle adnam pineau humphries

Humpries at 19 has looked a lot more comfortable in the nbl than what Ferguson did. Not sure how you think he is overrated.

Overrated

Hodgson - commits a lot of dumb fouls which prevent him from staying on the court.

Blanchfield - inconsistent shooter that doesn't offer too much else

Underrated

Wagstaff - just seems to play well every time I watch him

Creek - starting to get the credit he deserves but the guy rarely plays a bad game and brings it every night

Barlow's having his struggles with injury I believe.

I got the impression of tyler being underrated and humphries overrated watching sydney...

Yes because heaps of 19 year old big man have dominated the nbl like um um um?

Jack Toft - agree with Ogilvy.
It would seem there is some consensus in having Cadee in the team.

So who would be in the over-rated starting 5?

Seems like the consensus is

C Ogilvy
PF
SF
SG Cadee
PG

Hodgson to back up Ogilvy.

Goulding sg, cadee pg?

Barlow sf?

I don't think anyone overrates Johnson, there was a reason he was playing in Sweden before this.

Overrated:
- Newley / Penny / Barlow / Goulding (all once were good, now cooked)
- Cadde / Blanchfield

Underrated;
- Newbill / Buford / Conger (perhaps more a case of, just don't get the attention)

Worst:
- Teys.

He underrates Damian Martin horrendously.

If we're going to include Homicide ratings in this discussion we might as well list every player in the league, really.

Who is overrating Cadee? He cops it on the forum all the time.

I actually think he's an OK wild card to have off your bench, just not helped by starting in place of Lisch. Might be weak defensively, but routinely hits critical threes when I'm watching games.

The first post answers your question.

This is the difficulty with a topic like this: you have to work out whose ratings you're using. The consistency in names coming up here indicates that most of them probably aren't over/underrated unless you can specifically cite some other rating from somewhere.

Under rated

1. Perry Ellis been puttin up huge numbers. Is unguardable

Check him out at the other end. Horrible defender.

There in lies the Kings problems...defensively

Cadee putrid
Randle Ordinary and too cooked from Gaze not resting him.
Ellis....see Cadee
Tyler Asked by Gaze not to try to defend in case he fouls.

I'm not sure how critical Cadee’s 3s could be Isaac, they’ve won 3 games...

What bothers me about Cadee is his inability to push the ball up the floor with any intensity and create half breaks. Watch his style, he has this slow bouncy way of moving the ball up the court, like he’d rather look good than have an impact.

In Thoesby’s defense, he may be a horrible player, but apparently is an excellent set shooter. I’ve not seen Gaze use him in this way, it seems like Gaze tries to use him as a regular shooting guard, when clearly he should just stand in a corner and wait for a kick out from Tyler or Humphrey B Bear

Over Rated this season would be Matt Hodgson and chris goulding.
I really don't get what the hype is about chris anymore.

Under Rated Players
Adam Doyle - plays such a solid game when on. Isn't given the opportunity to stand out in a team full of guards!
Majok Deng - killing it right now

Worst Player - Chris Patton

Bol, I watch Hawks games. I suspect a couple of those Kings wins have been against Illawarra!