#343, taking the ten best kids out of VC will absolutely dilute the quality of the competition. I know there are a lot of divisions and registrations are increasing, but that doesn't mean that the standard at the very top is the same whether you include the best team or not. If you isolate it to VC, at a very minimum, you're talking about the equivalent of removing the best team in the competition and replacing it with the worst. And that fails to consider the inappropriateness of the proposal for every other state, where the depth of talent is even less. It's conceptually fine, but unless they rescheduled it so, for example, u12s and u16s played on one day and u14s and u18s played on another day, it is practically unsound.
#348, being part of HP doesn't currently preclude kids playing rep, but under the proposal being discussed - namely that a state HP side of kids in one age group should be entered into the rep competition in the age group above - it would.