Anonymous
Years ago
Melbourne United referees stood down
Good to see. This is the minimum the league shouldve done although it won't help new Zealand in the win column
Anonymous
Years ago
Good to see. This is the minimum the league shouldve done although it won't help new Zealand in the win column
Should never be allowed back on a basketball court
Twice now, both involving favourable decisions for United.
Happy Days
Years ago
Credit Vickerman for keeping his cool.I would of got ejected watching that rubbish.
lol should never be allowed back on the basketball court.
OK Mr perfect go get your whistle and go and umpire some games for us and when you stuff up we will all ban you from the court too. no one is perfect, hopefully they learn from their mistakes and will be better in the future for it.
koberulz
Years ago
They didn't just stuff up, they had a ten-minute chat between them and some other bloke and ended up applying a rule that doesn't exist.
Train
Years ago
What realistic measures could they introduce to close the referee skilling gap - both long term and short term.
I can't see the NBL having the money to recruit Euro and NBA calibre referees to Australia. Could BA and the NBL work together to create some kind of Referee Academy?
Yeah because the NBA referees aren't corrupt at all.
Train
Years ago
I don't think the problem is that the ref's here are corrupt, I think its more lack of experience and poor decision making.
Isaac
Years ago
Blake Griffin talking about a botched call:
"Listen, reffing games is very hard, I tried to ref a Little League camp game this summer and it didn't go so well, so I know. This game’s going fast. I don’t think any of those guys missed it on purpose, I really don’t."
If you are going to do a job then do it right. They cost the breakers a win and punters a win. In some countries the refs would be shot dead for that.
So let me guess this straight? The owner of the NBL is also the owner of United?
koberulz
Years ago
That Griffin quote doesn't really apply, though. They got the sequence of events bang on, they just applied a rule that didn't exist after ten minutes of discussion. That's the sort of thing that's inexcusable.
Blowing calls in live play I can live with. But that? No.
Spot on Koberulz. Let's not put this on speed of the game type excuses. They had several conferences, took the heat out of it and this is what they came up with. It was either match fixing or horrible temperament. "hopefully" the latter.
Nike
Years ago
Nbl refereeing is not their job. It is a hobby/secondary pastime. The amount of money paid and time/effort given does not equate at this point in time.
If you want pro refs... Pay them as pro refs so they can devote their time/attention to it without the distraction of a regular job!
Did the ref supervisor get stood down too?
The fulltime ref comment is a joke. What pay them more and they will suddenly do a better job?
You can't teach commonsense.
Commisioner
Mark Boyd
Referees
Matt Townsend
Raoul Kirsten
Tim Brown
Game commissioner Mark Boyd......not referee commissioner.
Bear
Years ago
I think that was the one thing missing in the whole scenario, the application of common sense, very hard to teach because it is very hard to find...
Raoul Kirsten has always been a dodgy ref I reckon...
Not a ref
Years ago
I know people are upset but according to some on this thread there is no possible way the referees can improve, and they should be taken somewhere and shot for that performance, as long as it's not a basketball court which they should never step on again dead or alive.
Can understand the red hot anger over a bad call (Lowrey 2001 still burns) and the passion is a good thing but the rhetoric is a little extreme.
PeterJohn
Years ago
"The full time ref comment is a joke. What pay them more and they will suddenly do a better job?"
As a volunteer official in another sport, it definitely will. There's a world of difference when you have have 50-60 extra hours a week to fit in regular review of rules, watching game tapes and practising decision making with video. The alternative is they only get that level of practice in the games themselves and for a few hours here and there.
Just like the athletes and administrators, professionalism of officials creates a career path that makes it worthwhile investing the effort to become really good. It also gives the league more leverage over referees who rely on game payments for their livelihood, instead of it being just a little earner on the side.
What would be interesting to know is what level of professionalism is there at the moment among NBL refs. i.e., are refs paid to train/practise as well as officiate games, like players are? How much do they train each week? What do they get paid for games? Are any of them full-time basketball refs?
Thunder Jam
Years ago
What hope do we have when they keep calling charges when the defender has one foot in the air?
mystro
Years ago
They have sorted the issue with the poor decision making by the Refs, now what about the flopping issue?
Games should be able to be video reviewed post match by a Refereeing Panel and fines/suspensions given for Unsportsmanlike conduct and Flopping that may have been missed by the game Refs.
MACDUB
Years ago
Is it worth the NBL throwing money at getting a very highly skilled FIBA referee official over here to train, monitor and develop and upskill refereeing talent?
Differences in the quality of refereeing is just like the differences in quality of players - there's your Lebrons, Steph Currys, Westbrooks etc and there's your local social league player who can't make a layup.
The positive is that that social league player will probably never be a Westbrook, Curry or Lebron.
But in the refereeing sense, the social league guy can be a Westbrook, Curry or Lebron. Training, education and time.
mystro
Years ago
I agree Macdub, it would be great to have a senior International Fiba Ref as the Referee's Commissioner in charge of improving/maintaining the standard of refereeing in the NBL.
I wonder how much someone qualified would cost per season?
The head of FIBA ran a course here a month ago.
DaAnswer
Years ago
Wow, glad to see the NBL implement immediate rule changes too!
Also in second Video, why the f**k is Homicide running onto the court to celebrate with Goulding? @0:18sec
DaAnswer
Years ago
Whoops, Link:
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/basketball/nbl-referees-stood-down-over-farcical-finish-to-melbourne-united-v-new-zealand-clash/news-story/32148e20587c59d18c42c45629966779
paul
Years ago
I think FIBA have got their own issues sorting out the reffing at the moment to be honest, I'm not sure the FIBA template is what the NBL needs to sell itself as a product at the moment.
Supernintendo Chalmers
Years ago
Andrew Gaze wants refereeing shut down for a year.
Nathan of Perth
Years ago
Successive weeks of referees being stood down over games involving calls leading to close wins to Melbourne United.
Great team but they're riding their luck!
paul
Years ago
Well if you want to run some conspiracy theories check out the foul out stats!
https://twitter.com/nblfacts/status/663886220313755648
koberulz
Years ago
What hope do we have when they keep calling charges when the defender has one foot in the air?Why do you keep bringing this up? It's irrelevant.
Koberulz, he just wants to continually highlight the fact that he has absolutely no concept of the rule. Next he will start to promote standing still with your hands crossed in front....
paul
Years ago
I think that one may have sailed over your head Kobes.
Anon
Years ago
Hope Goulding is happy with himself. Getting a reputation of being a me first player under the guise of for the team first and getting the win doing whatever it takes. Unfortunately refs and announcers getting drawn in is affecting their own credibility and he is getting off scott free. Time for his coach to give him a sit down talk on professionalism and how to give and more importantly how to show respect if he is to go anywhere in this game. Betting Europe and NBA got a glimpse of his attitude and thought 'high risk' over gee we can develop this guy he has talent.
Supernintendo Chalmers
Years ago
I would love to know what the attending NBA (Dallas?) scout thought of that ending?
Bear
Years ago
I don't think he would have though too much of it actually, maybe a shake of the head and a small blessing that he will soon return to the U.S.A...
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 9:43 am, Tue 14 Jan 2025 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754