Anonymous
Years ago
The F***king Flopping in the Nbl
Unfuckingbelievable!!! The United will win the NBL Finals if the game is called like this.
Anonymous
Years ago
Unfuckingbelievable!!! The United will win the NBL Finals if the game is called like this.
Langers
Years ago
Can't believe they called USF on that. Goulding is a great player but my goodness he flops.
Happy Days
Years ago
I agree...Breakers copped the pineapple this afternoon.Unsportsmanlike please!!!
So how many comments here from accredited refs? ZERO.
NBL Fan
Years ago
Well to be fair anon, the refs this year are reffing like they are unaccredited.
Kr
Years ago
What is the criteria for unsportsmanlike? I understand something about not going for the ball, excessively rough and open lane to the hoop type scenario, but how does an off the ball push off qualify for uslf?
Supernintendo Chalmers
Years ago
It was a dead ball for about a tenth of a second. Common sense should have prevailed.
The NBA final 2 minute rule is only against the defensive team, not the offensive team. The 2 fouls would have cancelled each other out.
koberulz
Years ago
It was a dead ball for about a tenth of a second. Common sense should have prevailed.It should have, but the question was by what criteria it could have been called an unsportsmanlike.
The NBA final 2 minute rule is only against the defensive team, not the offensive team. The 2 fouls would have cancelled each other out.This isn't the NBA.
Kr
Years ago
Thanks koberulz, I guess technically correct call then. You would have thought that rule was meant to apply in an in bounding the ball situation, not when two fouls happen almost simultaneously. Seems a bit ridiculous with the game on the line.
Read the fiba laws. Specifically 37.1.1 . Anot unsportsmanlike foul on a dead ball is only when the ball is still in the hands of the official or in bounding player. Also can only be committed by the defensive team.
koberulz
Years ago
Yeah, I think that was one of the ones that changed last year. Forgot about the change.
LV
Years ago
The refs should be allowed to use common sense discretion in that situation. It was "dead ball" by literally a tenth of a second.
koberulz
Years ago
They are allowed to, and the dead ball rule didn't apply anyway. They just screwed NZ, completely contrary to the rules, because:
1. They felt like it.
2. They have no idea how to officiate basketball or what the rules are.
3. The league is set up for Melbourne to win.
I have no idea which of those three options is the least bad, but none of them are good.
Touch the rim
Years ago
What really annoys me is that all three refs knew a wrong call was made but didn't change it (could they have rescinded it?), yet they didn't try to make up for it by calling the fouls simultaneous. That's all it would have taken!
Also, who was the old bloke the referees consulted about the unsportsmanlike rule technicality? A ref briefed Vickerman on the decision, Vickerman then told the ref that he better take this time and get the call right, so the ref then went over to the score bench to talk to this guy. Who was he?
Isaac
Years ago
Is this the foul where Goulding had his arm around Webster and then flopped? But Majok had rushed the Breaker in the meantime?
What were the calls on that play?
The only possible unsportsmanlike foul that could have occurred was Goulding holding Webster prior to the inbound. Absolutely nothing else couldo be on that play. If they can spend 5 minutes talking about it why can't they look at the rules?
Wilson Sting
Years ago
Or Kickert holding TeRangi. As equally unsportsmanlike but not even mentioned because TeRangi didn't flop.
swish
Years ago
Flopping works!
Players do what they can to win. It is what we expect of them.
Ref's have to make the calls.
Have to hope players with a rep as a flopper will eventually cost their team in big games as ref's decide not to call fouls for players they have come to beleive have fooled them in the past.
Anon
Years ago
and as Dr Phil says, How is that flopping working for you Chris... MMMMmmmmm Europe, nope too many issues and sent packing….. US, nope sent packing… Thinks he is king of the castle here in Aus but we are not fooled. Be prepared Chris for the biggest roasting in NBL history on your road run
Isaac
Years ago
They just need to bring in and enforce video reviews of any flops and it will gradually be removed from the game.
Bear
Years ago
I agree Isaac, if they are able to spend two minutes and still stuff up their decisions, surely they can spend 30 seconds to review a possible flop call/charge call to get it...........errr, right?
Supernintendo Chalmers
Years ago
I think Isaac maybe meant post game, not during it.
Bear
Years ago
Even in that case, it may reduce the number of flops over time but it wouldn't change an outcome. Still, something needs to happen if we are to see more consistent calling, so yeah let's try it...
Bake
Years ago
The refs were consistent.
When it gets close be prepared for a "Kirston Call" to assist Melbourne, it happened v Sixers and on other occasions.
It's best to keep on side with the NBL's owner
LV
Years ago
Yeah- video review will reduce it.
Question just becomes: What is an appropriate penalty?
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 12:21 am, Fri 22 Nov 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754