I think it did.
Larry Bird from all accounts loved everything about Danny Granger pre-injury, so for him to pull the trigger on that trade he MUST have known his career as a key contributor on a contender was over.
Voulgaris is on the money in that Scola has been horrible as well. He has never been any good on the defensive end, but this year he seems to be another step slower, and his fluid offensive game isn't nearly as effective as it was in the past. There was a time when he was like a poor-man's Kevin McHale: you could give him the ball and he would go worm, spin, pivot and contort his way into a bucket, but he just hasn't been able to do that this year.
Maybe he's not getting the ball where he likes (i have noticed there's been a lot more 18 footers hurled than in the past where he has primarily worked from the low block).
Forgetting the poor form of several guys, I just don't think have enough two-way players for a relatively young coach in Vogel to make this work.
Other than 4 guys (1-4 in the starting lineup), every other rotation player on the roster is giving something massive up when he is on the floor.
With Hibbert it's footspeed and offense.
With Scola it's footspeed and defense (anyone with even half a face up game just kills him, especially when he gets caught on a switch and has to guard a smaller guy.)
With Evan Turner it's defense, outside shooting and basketball IQ.
With Copeland it's defense.
With Mahinmi it's offense.
CJ Watson doesn't really have any gaping holes in his game but he just goes missing for ages. Funny how that can happen to a point guard when you tell him that he's not going to be handling the ball while he's on the floor. See also: Hill, George.
I thought they were ready to contend and drank the Indiana cool-aid hard earlier this year, but that Granger trade for me was a panic move. I questioned it then and it's obviously played out like this. Granger was never going to do much for this team but at least he was familiar with the guys and could knock down the corner three. They needed to trade for a Matt Barnes type if anything. Turner was a risk and it backfired.
I can't remember a contender melting down like this for such a sustained period in my (albeit short) lifetime as an NBA fan.
But who knows? Maybe they come out in a couple of days and blow Washington away and then beat Miami in 7 and all this talk seems like ancient history. Stranger things have happened. Maybe Turner has some as yet unknown matchup-related purpose that will come to light in the next round should the Pacers get there.
On the plus side, they have played terribly (even in the games they have won it has been really bad basketball), and are a win away from the conference finals...