You know what we all have opinions, none of us are right or wrong. You can't pick individual games to evaluate players. This is done over some time. These kids have been watched and evaluated for several years now over several tournamanents, not just National Champs. Nationally it starts at the U14 Club Championships. That was 3 & 4 years ago for this group. I think everyone in the know knows these kids and their game.
No doubt Victoria has a lot of depth compared to other states (NSW would as well) and they could probably put two Vic Metro and two Vic Country teams in the Nationals and do better than most other teams. This is to be expected given the greater populations in those states.
However, to say there are other Vic Metro players capable of making the Australian U17 squad team is fanciful. Other Vic kids could make other State teams, but not the Aus U17 squad.
I will preface the above with - depth is dependent upon the individual age groups. For 3 years NSW Metro were the Champions of the U18's before losing to Vic Metro in a close final in Brisbane (2013). All 4 of these finals were close affairs that could have gone either way. Also, I remember Vic Metro were lucky to win against NSWC & Tas in 2013! For these 4 years NSW Metro & Vic Metro have been the dominant states, but not by that much. Now, I think think this (2014) Vic Metro group is the dominant group. They won easliy two years ago and were not really threatened in Canberra. Last year in the U16 Final it was an all NSW affair, so, fair to say in the age group belwo NSW is the dominant state.
But that is not to say that the other states don't have some quality kids, they do. Unfortunatley for the other states they don't have the population of NSW & Vic and by extension don't have the week in week out quality of competition. That makes it hard for them. So it is a super effort by any of them who make it to Aus camps.
Congratulations to the Vics for having promoted the game and getting a lot of kids playing it.
If you were at the Nationals, watched the games, looked at the stats, then I think there would be very few (MAYBE ONE or two) kids that could be genuinely disappointed they weren't picked in the squad above.
But remember, if they weren't picked who would they dislodge to get in?
IMO the rest are just not in this class, or at least their performances haven't indicated they are. Generally, for their positions most of the kids that got selected were the most dominant performers for their position.
IMO I think coaches have selected a very well balanced squad from the kids that were available.
Also, you know what, despite what we think here it won't change anything. The squad's been picked, the rest is conjecture.
Good luck to the kids in the squad. For whoever finally makes the team for the worlds, fantastic opportunity, you deserve it and do us proud.