That was not well said at all.
here were calls that went both ways, it was far from one sided. The free kick count was only in favour of the hawks by two. And when there are 46 free kicks awarded, a difference of two is not much at all.
That's under an assumption that teams commit actions that deserve a free kick with roughly the same amount. I'd say in this case not giving a 50m penalty for the Hawthorn runner going through the mark is a clear screw up, as is an umpire making the wrong call from 100m away, or the 50M penalty that should not have been given which resulted in a goal for the Hawks.
We aren't saying the Crows were robbed of the game, but the umpiring plainly sucked. You're running on the formula of "1 horrible call against the Crows is the same as 1 50/50 call against the Hawks". I'm not saying all calls against the Crows are horrible by any means, what I am saying is giving 50M penalties away or the omission of doing so when it's deserved is very different to "that could have been holding the ball, maybe"
Basically, don't look at it in the way of "only in favour by two", it's not a reasonable test for "bias".
If the Hawks lost, the Hawks fans would be calling the umpires names and the Crows fans would be saying it was good umpiring.
That would not have been the case at all, crap umpiring is crap umpiring. Victorian fans feel screwed over if they get reasonable calls against them when playing a non-vic team, as it's quite outside their comfort zone.
It's simply a superficial response to make themselves feel better, because heaven forbid that they actually admit that their team lost because they couldn't hack it in the final moments.
That's a silly cheap shot that does not deserve respect. Adelaide played one of their best matches period, especially one of their best finals. Is there disappointment in losing? Yes. Are we proud of how well Adelaide competed and how well they played? Absolutely. We saw a very good display of football from both Adelaide and Hawthorn and I don't think anyone expected Adelaide to play so damn well. Suffice to say that the comment "couldn't hack it in the final moments" is a completely ignorant argument, Adelaide did anything but choke this match, they served it up to the number one team in their home ground and came away with less than one goal difference, that is not choking by any means.
I don't expect the Crows to make top 4 next year, they had too many easy wins this year with a soft schedule but they'll be a very tough out in the finals.
You can only beat who you play. Did Adelaide have an easy schedule? Yes, but what Adelaide have shown this year is that they were undoubtedly a top 4 team. Only Hawthorn (top team) and Collingwood (bogey team) were really comparative, and Sydney which Adelaide beat during the year. In terms of Finals, Adelaide beat Freo and as we saw served it up to the Hawks. If anything, with our young side we could very well see Adelaide taking the next step to the Grand Final next year. To say that Adelaide won't be a top 4 team next year without knowing any of the offseason movements, using it on simply the stupid basis that Adelaide aren't a top 4 team this year if it wasn't for the schedule is complete nonsense.
the pressure of the Crowvertiser
It's amusing that people call it The Crowvertiser, considering the chief writer is a Port supporter and at least half of the football writers are not Crows supporters (granted several are Victorian syndicated from the Herald Sun). It's also amusing that people expect Adelaide media to not focus on an Adelaide team, or maybe people feel that it's weird to not read such victoriancentric coverage as we see on the Footy Show or Herald Sun, The Age, AFL.com.au or Fox Sports? They could not give a toss about an Adelaide team, but it's fair that in an Adelaide market, the Adelaide Crows or Port Power are the headlines.
---
Don't let the disgust about the umpiring diminish just how proud Adelaide supporters are of the Crows efforts and just how well they played against the Premiership favourites who we all know are an incredibly strong team. It must be acknowledged that there is some space to vent about umpiring, as it is such a big feature of the game and to just say "oh it's just whining" or "it was the same number of free kicks anyway" is a pretty pathetic and frankly uneducated approach, those arguments could be made by people who never saw the game or don't know what the game even is. Congratulations to the Hawks and Sydney in making the big stage, and it was great that the game I watched was not dirty and it was genuinely a brilliant game even though my side did not come up victors in the end.