Lucy
Years ago

Netball SA sued for on-court collision

I just saw on the Adelaide TV news that a netball player has taken legal action for injuries suffered during an on-court incident at ETSA Park in 2007. She suffered disabling injuries when she collided with another player from a neighbouring court who ran onto her court to chase a stray ball.

She is suing Netball SA, the other player and her club. I think the girl's name is Candice Burton.

This case, if successful, will have serious ramifications for Basketball in SA (players and clubs) where, like netball, courts are located next to each other.

Topic #26356 | Report this topic


ringlord  
Years ago

Last year i saw a girl get her leg caught in the net at port Adelaide,then a player from the other court stepped on her protruding leg.Court 2 at mt Barker had a boy smash his head on the wall which is around a few inches from the sideline.

Reply #331264 | Report this post


Latrentis  
Years ago

I've seen a child run into the glass door/windows at MSAC....they are way too close to the court!

Reply #331267 | Report this post


Jack Toft  
Years ago

The standard of infrastructure at courts in SA can be said to be woeful at the least.

Workcover have a massive unfunded liability and they are currently going through a round of litigation that will only seem to escalate over time. Workplace Services are under a lot of pressure to "shoot first, ask questions later" with a "let the courts work it out" approach.

There needs to be a minimum standard with respect to courts. Hazards located within a set distance from the playing surface need to be assessed and risks mitigated.

In the event of an accident, questions will be asked. Those questions relate to risk identification, risk assessment and risk control. In particular, what "reasonable steps" were taken to minimise the risk or eliminate the hazard.

Any player injured as a result of a ball entering their court from a neighbouring court can take civil action in the courts and expect a very good chance of a win. The question will be asked "where is your risk assessment?" No risk assessment? Expect to pay lots. With a risk assessment? Expect to pay less.

Reply #331268 | Report this post


alexkrad  
Years ago

pretty sure there is a standard set out by fiba?

sure there is an australian standard too

Reply #331271 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I am sure the standards don't include water leaking from roofs onto courts while people are playing and training

Reply #331275 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

if court two at mt barker can be used for district games, then surely campbelltown leisure centre can, mt barker is even shitter than campbelltown

Reply #331278 | Report this post


opt  
Years ago

Remember the old (I think) forestville court 2, where the wall/back of grandstand of court 1 was about a meter from the court. Felt as if it was 30cm away when you where trying to inbound the ball.

Reply #331282 | Report this post


Cat in the Hat  
Years ago

The wall ran almost directly along the sideline. The gap was WAY less than a metre. It had the dotted lines inside the court that you could stand behind to inbound. In hindsight it was so dangerous!

Reply #331283 | Report this post


Rock  
Years ago

If I can add some sensibilities to the conversation.... so playing on an outside court 20 years ago (or a bit more) means I can sue someone because I hurt my knee? Get a friggin grip !!

As much as I think Hillcrest and Marion need to work hard to address the problems (read Basketball SA + local council) let's stay calm and try to be constructive in making sure things get fixed sooner rather than later.
Lobby people strategically at the council level (a la Knox in Vic) and get the powerful people to take notice. There is Federal money there for organisations to provide valid community activities such as organized sport.

Reply #331290 | Report this post


lockstock  
Years ago

Jack Toft I'd be interested to know where you pull your analysis from. Is it from a legal background or a commercial one?

Because from a legal standpoint I don't see how really any of what you are saying is accurate... for example, what does Workcover have to do with it? The netball player wasn't at work, was she?

Don't want to seem like a c*nt, but there are lots of incorrect statements in your post, I'm sorry to point out.

Reply #331291 | Report this post


lockstock  
Years ago

And Rock, for the record, no you couldn't sue for something that happened 20 years ago.

Reply #331292 | Report this post


Mystro  
Years ago

I want to sue every local council for injuries suffered by stray skateboards at skateparks and small children in the way.

Reply #331295 | Report this post


Jack Toft  
Years ago

Workcover from the umpires perspective

Reply #331296 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Actually my kid fell over in the macdonalds playground, I want free burgers for life!!!! Does it matter it was 16 years ago.

Reply #331297 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I've seen you Anon and you already look like your getting free burgers for life!!

Reply #331326 | Report this post


Hanging Round  
Years ago

Do all "Anon's" look the same?

Reply #331331 | Report this post


ankles  
Years ago

From personal experience as manager of a sports facility in NSW some years ago.

First week on the job, father and son hire a bowling machine, son has his go, Dad decides to step up to the plate (his Workcover statement admits inexperience, no skill, and fear). Who knows what happened - I suspect kid lets the ball go before Dad's ready or is picking up balls (kid was 12 and precluded from operating the machine). Short story - Dad gets sat on his arse with a mouthful of blood and some bruises. Dad is a laywer and lodges a claim through Workcover as well as through the courts.... for $750,000.

During the investigation I said to the Workcover guy why does the Dad, who admits not being up to it, not wear any responsibility - he said 'there's a fair bit of pride at stake with his son!' I did ask how proud he felt sitting there with a mouthful of blood.

Insurance company settled for $45K (without consultation with us) and put our insurance premiums up by $26K per annum. Workcover fined us 'only' $15K in light of the extensive mitigating work we had done post-injury (another $20K) and legals of $15K - all for what was in essence, a bruised jaw.

It's real and it happens (generally if the wrong person gets hurt - most of us would put ourtail between our legs and go home nurse our bruises). WorkCover AND the courts (at least in NSW).

Reply #331333 | Report this post


Isaac  
Years ago

That's rough. Great story though!

Reply #331334 | Report this post


HO  
Years ago

i particularly like the bit about the dad being sat on his arse. That's sort of like the moral to the story eh?

Reply #331336 | Report this post


o  
Years ago

The iron rails along the stairs to the bar at Pasadena have been one of my concerns for years. Thin with sharp corners.

Reply #331337 | Report this post


lockstock  
Years ago

Doesn't halp that some lawyers out there really push their client. I had a motorcycle accident a few months ago. Wasn't my fault. Some bumps, bruises, and quite a sore neck for a couple of weeks. Just wanted money for the bike, didn't want to claim compensation for injury. Stated that to my insurance lawyer at least 5 times. Nevertheless, they continued to claim, continued to claim, and next thing I know 2 months later I have an appointment with a specialist. Are you retarded??? So I had to cancel that and explain AGAIN I just want to be paid out for my bike and ripped gear/helmet.

F*cking lawyers.

Reply #331389 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Reply #351457 | Report this post




You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.



Close ads
Little Streaks - The fun and interactive good-habits app designed especially for kids.
Serio: Tourism photography and videography

Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.

Recent Posts



.


An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 9:24 am, Wed 27 Nov 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754