If Big Red really wants to come home, he has to be high in our considerations. Being able to rotate him, Balls and DJ at the 4 and 5 spots would be awesome.
For me, the only two reasons why you wouldn't sign him are:
1) If the price precludes us getting top-notch backcourt help (ie, Martin, Gibbo or a Homicide level import). I actually think the backcourt is a more pressing issue for the Sixers. We desperately need a playmaker who will make our offence work. This becomes especially important with Schensch onboard because he won't be effective unless he has a guard who can get him the ball in the right spots.
2) If you thought you couldn't get DJ enough time to keep him happy. To me, he will be better in the long run than Big Red because of his scoring ability. I also think in the long run he will be a better 4 than 5 and so he is the perfect succession plan for Balls once he starts to slow down.
Paul, this lineup that you posted earlier:
Schenscher, Ballinger, Hill, Herbert, Williams
Johnson, Dowdell, Creek, Ng, Daley
I'd be pretty happy to start the season like that! Its a nice balanced roster with plenty of size up front and I think enough long range shooting to get by with Ng, Balls, Herbert and Dowdell.
I'm not holding my breath though, considering the Sixers money woes and recent track record with signing duds!