I think much of the criticism of Jacob Holmes is a little off the mark. His shooting percentage from the field is terrible, no dispute, but there are three reasons for this: 1) his flat shot - when he does miss, it always looks worse than it is 2) he tends to end up with the ball at the end of the shot-clock alot, which again doesn't help, 3) as a good offensive rebounder he is credited with a lot of shot attempts on tip-in attempts, many of which he doesn't have a lot of control over (David Cooper is the same). I personally think Holmes has played really well this year.
Oscar Forman has been the big surprise for me. He should win the 6th Man of the Year award, and he is one of the few Adelaide players who have consistently played better away from the Dome than at it. He has even become a presence on the boards this year, which I never thought would happen.
David Cooper has proven to be a perfect fit, though Paul Rees has been practically useless in the second half of the season. There has to be someone else we can get for the 15-20 minutes per game he is playing who won't get so touched up on the boards.
Brad Hill has been a great pickup, though now that Brett Maher is back the minutes aren't going to be there. Personally I would always have him ahead of Darren Ng, who really has made no forward progress this season. He's great at hitting the three, providing we are already up double figures.
It has been good to see Todd Gower get a few minutes (if only a few) and to see him carve out a bit of a niche with the hustle plays. He is also very good defensively. He's just not tall enough to rebound strongly at the power forward spot.
I don't need to say anything about Maher, Farley and Dusty as they have just been great.
The best thing for Adelaide though was losing Mark Nash to injury. I'm sorry, but he's useless, and he would only have held back Holmes and Forman. His indecisiveness is cancerous. The best thing about Adelaide's offence this year is the quick ball movement and decision making. Nash would totally f*ck that up. They don't need him, he should not be signed for another year as he's basically been injured for three seasons. Same story Jason Williams. Eight years is enough.