I can tell you my sons experience; He is 15 years old. He had umpired for approx 2 years. In his time he had umpired regular junior district games, a few country carnivals, social games and a number of U18 & U20 games. He enjoyed the challenge and the extra spending money it gave him. He also met and became freinds with many new people he never normally would have met. He was graded well by his UIC and that was why he was able to be trusted to handle games that were way above his age level.
He has now turned his back on umpiring because of the recent changes that have been made to the system.
At the start of last season, or maybe the season before, he was asked to nomintae 2 or 3 stadiums that he could umpire at. He was then told that if he was available he would have to email the Umpires office a week before to say he was available. He did not have a say in what one of the 3 stadiums he was going to be sent too, or what times he would be rostered onto.
My son plays Div 1 for a district club so he was happy to umpire before or after his own matches at his home stadium. On some occasions he was asked to umpire before or after his game at another stadium that is close by when his team was playing there. This he happily did; he only ever refused an umpiring gig when he was injured or had another commitment.
This worked great. My son was able to play and umpire almost every friday night and put his hand up for most Saturday mornings at his home stadium.
With the new system he has thrown in the towel because it is to hard to organise and plan transport arrangements while playing at one stadium and umpiring at another. He gave the new system a try for the 1st 4 weeks. He went from umpiring every week, to umpiring once in four weeks.
We now keep getting a bill for a $25 umpire registration fee. We had never had this bill before the "new" changes were made.
I understand what they have tried to do; however what they have done is turn off a large amount of current players from umpiring. These kids needed to umpire when it was handy and convinient for them, not the other way around.
The last year my son umpired a full season he was even considering if he could make a living out of umpiring at an elite level. He now has lost interest completly.
Abuse did not worry him; the small pay did not worry him; it was not being able to choose when and where he played that has lost him to umpiring.