ASIO Agent
Years ago
I was watching some div 1 games last night and continually noticed that players had both hands on the ball carrier / cutter / and even the rebounder with no foul's being called.
Is it still not an instant foul or has it come under the advantage/disadvantage crap???
Have been told by numerous ref's at junior div 1 level that it falls under the advantage/disadvantage crap. My argument has and always will be is that it is an advantage to the defense and a disadvantage to the offense. I've also been told that palming th ball and changing pivot feet also falls under advantage/disadvantage crap.
I suggest that we can reduce BSA costs by not having any ref's at all and let the players decide if it is an advantage/disadvantage.
wow
Years ago
Anon you twit.
2 Hands on is a foul - No advantage comes in to it.
1 Hand on means it must not stay on (particularly with the ball handler)
If it restricts the offence then it is a foul.
wow, you have no idea of who i am so please do not call me a twit, it makes you look like 1.
My question then to your almighty response is, why isn't it called?
1ref
Years ago
Two hands on a player must be a foul because the player is being HELD in position.
It is in the points of emphasis for the NBL/WNBL/ABA.
wow
Years ago
I called you a twit because you have showed ignorance by not knowing the rules yet you go and make a comment about not having umpires and making calls yourself.
division 1 juniors to do not always have good umpires on the games and so the reason it is not always called is either they do not know the rules or heave forbid make mistakes
wow, please explain which rules i do not understand? And i shall call you a twit by not recognising sarcasm re: not having umpires.
"division 1 juniors to do not always have good umpires on the games and so the reason it is not always called is either they do not know the rules or heave forbid make mistakes"
They do have a senior umpire who should know the rules and also an umpire in charge who "should" be checking on the games at various stages, and as for mistakes, hey, everyone makes them.
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 3:48 am, Sat 23 Nov 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754
