Fezlington
Years ago
On the news tonight
Judd has ruled out both teams
Now comes down to the Blues V Pies for his rights
I would say Carlton would be in the box seat for his services
Fezlington
Years ago
This is the AFL section numbnut....if you dont wanna read it dont click on it fool!!!
thomo
Years ago
interesting considering eagles have stated there intentions of not trading with collingwood
Fezlington
Years ago
True......also, why would they want to make the Pies...who just failed to be in the top 4 a stronger side
Carlton on the other hand are probably 2-3 years away before they will push for a top 4 position with Judd in the team
Its going to be a interesting week
The Journo
Years ago
Judd to Collingwood
Carlton to trade one of their first two picks to West Coast
Collingwood then trade on players and or picks to Carlton
Therefore, Collingwood won't have to deal directly with West Coast.
Peter Maravich
Years ago
at the end of the day, it comes down to which ever club can give the eagles adequate compensation.
M Dizzle
Years ago
Must remember what ever Judd has accomplished with the Eagles, unless he can get some new groins he's not much use to anyone.
thomo
Years ago
going to be interesting trade week thats forsure just hope the whole "judd" trade doesnt hold up the other trades for the players sake
Dr Bullshit
Years ago
Its not what anyone has to offer the eagles. The eagles are stuffed here coz judd is goin no matter what. Its a situation like that of Nick Stevens at port where they got absolutely d**k all for him. Judd has left, what is given to west coast will not be equivilent to Judds value. I say Collingwood at this stage.
BennyBoy
Years ago
Why would Judd want to go to Carlton. He stated that he wanted to go to a premiership contending team and to be honest I cant see Carlton winning a premiership any time soon. Whilst Collingwood on the other hand were generally premiership contenders at this stage and if they were to get judd that would further bulster there chances. Id hate to say it but I think Judd will end up at Collingwood.
Sturty6ers
Years ago
Who will Collingwood trade for him? Buckley, Fraser, etc etc? Will this be a repeat of the Nick Stevens fiasco? Pies would likely offer a s*#tload of money and whatever draft picks they have. But will West Coast go for this?
If there is no agreement then Judd goes into the draft and could end up anywhere......
skink
Years ago
judd would fit nicely in the midfield with marc murphy,Carrazzo and nick stevens, or in the pocket with fev up forward. Thats if none of them get traded. carn the mighty blues.
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 5:18 am, Tue 1 Apr 2025 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754
