Breif story on Foxsports.

Not overly surprising as there was always the rumour but still it is major news

More like Collingwood the front runner I would think

Carlton have more to offer West Coast. They can also secure him without trading anything as well.

Collingwood have come out and said they are out of the running.

He'll end up at Carlton or Essendon you would think.

Imagine Calton with Judd and #1 draft pick and the other young players...wow

I would be rapt to see this man in the Navy Blue

the next diesel for the navy blues!

The only way Carlton will have the #1 draft pick if West Coast fail to broker a trade....and that is not likely with all other Victorian sides chasing him

The only way I can see Judd in anything other than a Blues jumper is for one fo the big Melbourne clubs to trade for Carlton's number 1 choice.

OR

Make a ridiculous trade in which West Coast are the big winners (ie. Hawks trade Hodge and Franklin for Judd)

BUT, then again West Coast will go for the best possible deal and won't do what Port Adelaide did to Nick Stevens and get no compensation for him.

I think a possible trade for Carlton to offer could be Fevola and one of the two prioity picks.

Therefore the Blues get Judd and still keep one of their top draft choices.

WCE won't take Fevola. They don't need him.

I'd throw #1, #3, and a player to WCE for Judd. I would hesitate at #1, #3, and #20 for the ony player in case Judd pulls a Greg Oden.

Reasonable?

If any other clubs are smart they might end up with a Carlton draft pick if they can broker a 3 or 4 way deal. Apparently the kid coming out of the TAC Cup this year is the best kid to ever play in it or something.

Why would Carlton bother trying to Negotiate a trade? All they need to do is offer him the most cash and tell him to wait for the draft. All they lose then for him is their #1 draft pick.

West Coast are quite possibly about to lose the best player in the AFL for not even a cent.

He will go to Essendon.

Bombers will give up Paddy Ryder and Brent Stanton and the number 5 pick.

I would love to see Judd at the mighty Blues. That would be a good replacement for the retired Kouta. Lord knows they need someone like him.

I cannot see Carlton giving picks 1 and 3 and another player for Judd though. Maybe pick 1 or 3 and another player plus some cash.

Rumour out of Melbourne is that Judd going to St Kilda as a board member ?????????????

Go to a team on the rise Juddy - the mighty Tiges!

Carlton wouldn't trade the number one pick anyway, I have a feeling they would offer the third pick + players.

Boys ...the rumor going around at carlton are that the Blues will offer the Eagles - Pick 3, Kennedy & Cash

Pratt wants results, and wants em fast

Depending on Whitnalls surgery, the Bulldogs are interested in him.....for late draft picks

Waites name has been mentioned as a possible name to trade as well

Cain Acklands time at Carlton will be short lived as well i have heard

I cant see Carlton giving up the No1 pick.....we need a ruckman.....and Kruezer is the perfect fit

Judd would be nice, but at this point a ruckman is the No1 requirement down at Optus Oval

I'd like to see Judd at the tigers, that would make richmond an exciting outfit for next season with a crapload of run

Great call Dr B - Coughlan back from injury, Johnson Mr reliable, Tuck, Daledio and Judd would be a pretty good run-on team

Geez lockstock for a tigers fan and a man whose livelihood depends on attention to detail you seem to have forgotten their best run and carry player in Nathan Foley .
Judd will definitley not be a tiger next year , why ? beacause he wants to be on a team that is going somewhere and the tiges generally run around in circles chasing their own tails while their master spins wonderful stories about rerebuilding and 5 year plans.

You forgot Foley there lockstock...most improved player in the competition this year by a fair stretch i would say.

My bad indeed. Had an awesome year

Rotate on this - Tiges for Premiers in '08. Put a buck on it

No worries champ !

Judd to Melbourne - Heard it here first.

We will wait and see.

Judd to the Dees

It'd be like winning a cheap lottery

When I say Dees i really mean Blues!